Incarnation or reincarnation
Article summary proposed by the Contacts review with LLM assistance
This article by Olivier Clément examines the belief in reincarnation, widely spread in the New Age context, by confronting it with the Christian doctrine of the Incarnation. Adopting a comparative theological approach, the author first shows that reincarnation as conceived by the contemporary West betrays its Asian sources by presupposing a stable individual identity, a notion of Judeo-Christian origin. He then analyzes the specifically Christian responses: the resurrection of bodies, the communion of saints, prayer for the dead, and divine mercy as alternatives to karmic logic. The article also examines Origenist hypotheses on the fate of the soul after death, rejected by the fifth ecumenical council. The main contribution lies in demonstrating that the Orthodox tradition offers rich and nuanced spiritual resources to address the questions raised by the contemporary revival of belief in reincarnation.
This article has not been translated yet — it is available in its French version here.
The rest of this article is reserved for subscribers of the Contacts review.
Subscribe to read more
Digital subscription · Immediate access to the Contacts library